Cover for Wonky Planets and Mineral Snowflakes with Dr Dominic Samra
Season 2 · Episode 32 November 2026

Wonky Planets and Mineral Snowflakes with Dr Dominic Samra

Featuring Dominic Samra

What if a planet could have cloudy mornings and clear evenings, forever? In this episode, Jeni and Lorenzo are joined by Dr Dominic Samra, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Chicago, to explore the strange weather of hot Jupiters. From mineral 'snowflakes' to powerful winds carrying clouds around entire planets, Dominic explains why these distant worlds are far from uniform, and how JWST is beginning to reveal the differences between their two sides.

Stay updated

Subscribe to our RSS feed

  • S1E533m

    2 February 2026

    The Clouds of distant worlds: a chat with Dr Sushuang Ma

    Explore the science of one of the trickier components of exoplanet science: clouds, as hosts Jeni and Lorenzo are joined by Dr Sushuang Ma, a researcher at King’s College London. Sushuang’s work centres on modelling and retrieving exoplanetary atmospheres. She shares the significance of temperature and the role it plays in determining the interesting characteristics of clouds, which are not the fluffy white water vapour clouds we are used to. Listen as the conversation guides you through the intriguing clouds of exoplanets and why we must go beyond the simple ‘opaque cloud’ models for the next generation of observations.

    • Exoplanet Atmospheres
    • JWST
    Episode details →
  • S1E633m

    16 February 2026

    Reflecting our World to understand others with Dr Giulia Roccetti

    Bring yourself back to Earth through an inspiring chat with Dr Giulia Roccetti, an ESA research fellow at the European Space Astronomy Centre in Madrid. Hosts Jeni and Lorenzo join Giulia for a discussion about the innovative approach of using Earth as a proxy for exoplanet research through the investigation of Earthshine. Giulia’s journey started from her ever-present passion for environmental science, which led her to research that combines atmospheric physics, climate science and exoplanet research. She now develops advanced radiative transfer models to simulate how planets interact with light, using Earth as the test. Listen as Giulia talks us through the ‘pinball’ path of photons between Sun, Earth and Moon, and the complexities of modelling Earth’s atmosphere.

    • Rocky Worlds & Habitability
    • Exoplanet Atmospheres
    Episode details →
  • S2E433m

    15 November 2026

    How JWST reveals the origin of distant worlds: a chat with Dr Amelie Gressier

    What can the atmospheres of distant worlds reveal about their origins? In this episode, hosts Jeni and Lorenzo talk with Dr Amélie Gressier from the University of Montreal about one of the biggest revolutions in exoplanet research, JWST. Amelie began her journey as a child where she often wondered about distant life in the universe. Her ever-growing passion led her to her research today, where she specialises in atmospheric characterisation and planetary chemistry. Listen as Amelie talks about how JWST is transforming exoplanet science and our understanding of small worlds. Explore super-Earths, sub-Neptunes and atmospheric chemistry through Amelie’s exciting conversation, along with the journey that led her to where she is today.  From the leap beyond Hubble to the future of studying rocky planets, discover why JWST is changing how we understand distant worlds.

    • Exoplanet Atmospheres
    • Rocky Worlds & Habitability
    • JWST
    Episode details →

Transcript

This transcript was generated automatically. It may contain errors, identify speakers incorrectly or differ from what was said in the episode.

LorenzoJeniDominic
Lorenzo

Welcome to Growing Worlds, the podcast where we explore the science of exoplanets through conversation with early career researchers on the frontline of discovery. I'm Lorenzo.

Jeni

And I'm Jenny. In each episode, we meet a guest who takes us behind the science of planets, stars, and the tools we use to understand them.

Lorenzo

For a long time, when we model an exoplanet atmosphere, we quietly made a very convenient assumption that the planet is the same everywhere. One temperature, one chemistry, one set of clouds. Simple and completely wrong.

Jeni

Because real planets have mornings and evenings, daysides and night sides. And with JWST, we are now actually starting to see that lopsidedness in the data. To guide us through what we're calling, affectionately, wonky planets. We're joined by Dr. Dominic Samra from the University of Chicago. Dominic, welcome to Growing

Dominic

Than hi Jenny and Lorenzo. Thank you. Thank you for having me.

Jeni

I'm so excited. Look at those wonky planets, right? can't get much cooler than that.

Lorenzo

Let's not get ahead of ourselves. First, Dominic is

Jeni

Yeah.

Lorenzo

a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Chicago, where he specialized in modeling how clouds form in exoplanet atmosphere working from the microphysics upward. Literally, how individual clouds particle nucleate grow and fall. He studied physics at Imperial College London, then completed a PhD at University of St. Andrews with what might be the best thesis title we have had on the podcast. Mineral snowflakes on exoplanets and brone dwarf. After that, he worked at the Space Research Institute in Graz, Austria, before moving to Chicago. There he used what is known as a quasi-2D cloud formation code to study how clouds form across entire hot Jupiter and what kind of asymmetries that might produce when we observe there with JWST.

Jeni

Now, although we have so much amazing science to dig into, we always like to start right at the beginning, which is with your journey. So, Dominic, tell us how did you get into astronomy, into exoplanets, and then how did you end up at clouds? And you can't say it's because you're British.

Dominic

Ha ha ha yeah, so it's a it's a it's a great chance to talk about this and like the inspiration for doing astronomy. So I I was born in in London in the UK. and the light pollution there obviously is is terrible. so I grew up quite close to the River Thames, right in the middle of it, you just have an ocean of of lights around you. So from the ages of until seven I was growing up in London and couldn't really see a a thing in the night sky. You can maybe see one or two bright stars. and then when we were seven, my family and I we moved to back to my mum's hometown in Lincolnshire. and

Jeni

Hmm.

Dominic

Lincolnshire is a much more rural county, smaller towns, much less light pollution. And so when we moved there, suddenly I saw these beautiful night skies completely black, f filled with stars, and then I got inspired to do amateur astronomy first. And so I bought a telescope and I used to do some little bits of very poor astrophotography. which was maybe a a boding for why I would become a theorist later. But I started doing

Jeni

Ha ha.

Dominic

I started doing amateur astronomy in my in my my parents' backyard, and then from

Jeni

Hm.

Dominic

there realized that I'm good at maths and science at school. this is a thing you can actually do at university. And then it sort of snowballed from there. So that's how I ended up doing

Jeni

Yeah. Amazing.

Dominic

physics.

Jeni

So in terms of then getting into the exoplanet, did you do maybe a particular project or did you just kind of like dive straight into it for the PhD?

Dominic

Yeah, so exoplanets is harder for me to pinpoint when I became excited about them. I know I was excited about them as early as the Kepler launch. So maybe most people probably

Jeni

Mm. That's two thousand and nine.

Dominic

exactly, yeah. So it's it's a little bit odd because I don't have a particular memory of watching the launch or anything like this, but I know I was aware of it. I know that I was, you know, excited about it and mentioning it to friends at school that there was gonna be this telescope that was gonna find all these planets around other stars.

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

So it somewhere in there I was I was interested in it. And so then that just of carried

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

through underneath all the way through my undergrad where I did a a a a straight physics course. So it wasn't an astrophysics specialization.

Jeni

Okay. Wasn't astrophysics, was straight physics.

Dominic

No, it's I had I had the choice to go to other universities. F Imperial doesn't offer a astrophysics course, or at least they didn't when I was there.

Jeni

okay.

Dominic

And so I was still very open-minded to doing all sorts of things. my dad is a doctor, so I thought about doing medical physics.

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

you MRI imaging and radionucleides, etcetera.

Jeni

Mm-hmm.

Dominic

that stuff also fascinated me. But I always had this undercurrent of that I knew I liked astronomy, and

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

exoplanets were somewhere in there as well. So in my second year we had a chance to write a for for one of the course credits we had a chance to write a science article, a public science article about

Jeni

Mm-hmm.

Dominic

any topic we liked in science. And that I picked the Kepler space mission. So that obsession had carried

Jeni

Mm, nice.

Dominic

through until I i i even through to my undergrad. So yeah,

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

somewhere in there is w where exoplanets got me hooked.

Jeni

Yeah. And so then the PhD project, you were like, it's gonna be explants, man. Can't be anything else.

Dominic

Yes, but it was actually a little bit of a a bit of fortune that I ended up with that project. So during my master's at that time at Imperial there weren't really any professors who were doing exoplanet science. there were a couple of people who did brown dwarfs, but they weren't offering any master's projects. So for my master's dissertation I did a project on debris discs, which

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

are the remnants of planetary systems. It's the dust, it's equivalent to the asteroid belt and the Kuiper belt in our solar system. and so I did a pro a project on that, and it was a strictly observational project. So we were looking at archival data from a space telescope called Herschel, which also looked in the infrared.

Jeni

I know all about Herschel. Herschel, 'cause I'm a I'm a like Cardiff baby in terms of like my my undergrad and PhD and like I I worked with Herschel data in my masters and everything. So I'm like,

Dominic

Yeah.

Jeni

Herschel, yeah. Yeah, yeah. They

Lorenzo

We are quite big on aeroshell here in Cardiff.

Dominic

Yeah.

Jeni

made like the instruments and stuff at Cardiff, right?

Dominic

Yeah, exactly, exactly. So yeah. So that was my was my master's was using actually galactic survey data to look

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

for debris discs that are just captured in the foreground of these deeper surveys. and so I really loved that project and I was you know, i it was not so clear to me that I had to do exoplanets then for a PhD. I knew I wanted to do a PhD, but what I learned during that project I thought was I like, I really, really love doing stuff with observations, using real data. And so all of the positions I applied for for my PhD were were mostly observationally driven. They were exoplanets mostly, but they were

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

all heavily focused on doing yeah, observations of some kind. and St. Andrews, actually, I applied for a different project at St. Andrews. and the way it worked at St. Andrews was you got interviewed, and then if they wanted to give you a position, they asked you to rank your projects.

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

And so I

Lorenzo

Okay.

Dominic

actually ranked two observational projects ahead of this one.

Lorenzo

Okay.

Jeni

so it was like third choice lucky.

Dominic

Right, exactly. and also during the interview day I didn't get a chance to talk to the supervisor of this project. So that's why it was always like lower down on my list was they were not

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

at the university that day, so I was a little bit uncertain of like exactly how much I would enjoy this project and working.

Jeni

Well yeah, 'cause you Yeah, 'cause you don't know if you get on with the person 'cause you haven't met and that's so important when you're choosing a PhD project. It's almost like, fifty percent of it is are you interested in the topic? And then fifty percent of it is can you work with this person for three to four years?

Dominic

Yeah, yeah. So yeah, so the interview day was sort of a mixed bag for me because I I w went up on the train the night before, interviewed, and then got a train back down. And on the train back down they sent me the email saying, Yes, we would love to offer you a position. Can you rank these?

Jeni

That's amazing though, to know so quickly.

Lorenzo

Wow.

Dominic

Yeah, I think I had the fortune of being on the last interview day that they had scheduled that year. So they were able to, you know, look at all the candidates and then they could send a

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

a a thing, send an offer immediately.

Jeni

Top tip, everyone listening. Interview on the last day. Avoid the stress.

Dominic

Yeah. I don't

Lorenzo

Right.

Dominic

know if that helps with the stress though, because you spend you spend so long before the interview worrying about it. So it's maybe a bit s Cesaw or Swings and Roundabouts. Yeah, exactly.

Jeni

Double edged sword. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Dominic

but yeah, so I they they said that and then I was able to rank the projects and then a couple days later they got back to me and said, Okay, the first two projects you wanted are or are already assigned to other students. so

Jeni

Mm-hmm.

Dominic

would you s take your third choice? And so that was a bit of a a a tipping point for me, because I was like, Okay.

Jeni

Yeah, it's like mm yeah, do I want it? Yeah.

Dominic

Yeah. And so somewhere buried on my phone, probably still, I have a picture

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

because I went into a lecture theatre at Imperial College. This was after the this was in one of the some I think it must have been in the spring holiday, the Easter holidays. but

Jeni

Mm-hmm.

Dominic

yeah, so I had a I have a picture of I went into a lecture theatre and wrote down a pros and cons list. Of reasons to take the position and reasons not. Because I knew I really wanted to do a PhD,

Jeni

I love that.

Dominic

but I'd had this wonderful experience doing observational research. And I was

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

ri really not sure I could do this theory computational research. And

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

so I wrote down like a big pros and cons. And yeah, in the end, I don't remember if they were actually equal length or so, but you know, I thought about it for a few days, and in the end I thought, I'm gonna try it. Let's see. Never

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

d never done anything like this before. Certainly hadn't done a a huge amount of atmospheric. physics. I'd

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

done one course during my undergrad. and I was just like, let's just

Jeni

Yeah. But they obviously thought you were capable, otherwise they wouldn't have offered you it.

Dominic

Yeah, I must have done something good in the interviews. I don't know how I pulled the wool over their eyes, but I'm sure everyone has that feeling in academia.

Lorenzo

It worked, it worked, it worked up, yeah, so

Jeni

I think everyone

Lorenzo

that's great.

Jeni

does this like how am I here? I think that's just what everyone's like. All of adult life people are just like, I I don't know, but I'm just gonna carry on.

Dominic

Yeah, yeah, exactly. Exactly. So I was like, Well, I'm gonna try this and if it goes terribly wrong I can always get back on the train and come back to London and figure something else out to do.

Jeni

Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And so this is where the journey into clouds begins.

Dominic

Yes, exactly.

Jeni

By accident, quite by accident.

Lorenzo

Mineral slow flakes, right? How

Dominic

Yeah, so yeah, sorry. So yeah, that's a g a great name have to give credit to my supervisor for coming up with that name. We went to a conference in the south of France. and on the way back from that conference, we had a a flight delay for many hours. And so we sat in the gate at Geneva Airport and we're discussing

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

what what I really wanted, you know. This was in the first couple of months of my PhD. So I'd started to get to grips with the model, etc. they've they have an established cloud model that they were using, so I was playing around with that, but we were trying to ponder, you know, what science questions shall we actually ask with this model?

Jeni

Yeah.

Lorenzo

Mm-hmm.

Dominic

And yeah, we talked for for quite a few hours about i i like interests and one of the possibilities was porous particles, irregularly shaped particles.

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

and yeah, from the from there we we that that project started and then somewhere months down the line we came up with this idea of calling them mineral snowflakes.

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

and so maybe I can explain a little bit about where that name comes from and the ideas behind it.

Lorenzo

Yes, please. But I will ask you to start a little farther back because

Dominic

yeah.

Lorenzo

we only talk about clouds in season one. And no, it might be it might be good for for all our listeners to have a little to refresh their mind on what what do we what do we mean when we talk about clouds on like hot Jupiters and exoplanets in general because people will expect like no Well if I think about clouds and I'm a scientist, but if think about clouds I can st I still think about white shapes in the sky, which might not be what we expect on hot Jupiters.

Dominic

Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, that's a great yeah, we I should when you work on this for so long you get so used to the idea that the image are are vivid in your mind. But yeah. Yeah.

Jeni

Yeah. Yeah, of course. And that is why we're here to pull you back and be like Dominic,

Lorenzo

Yeah.

Jeni

it's amazing, but we gotta get the bigger picture before we zoom in. that's that's what

Dominic

Yeah.

Jeni

that's our job. So don't you worry.

Dominic

Yeah, absolutely. So, like Lorenzo said, the image that comes to mind with clouds is these fluffy water clouds that we have in the skies on Earth. and really you can cross out pretty much everything you have in your mind about that picture for hot Jupiter clouds. So

Jeni

Mm, okay.

Dominic

hot Jupiters are planets that are the size of Jupiter, but they orbit very close to their star. They orbit their star on on they go around their star every less than days. order of days, a few hours.

Jeni

My God Yeah.

Dominic

And so they are incredibly hot. Hence the name hot Jupiter. And by incredibly hot I mean thousands of degrees Celsius. So

Jeni

So that's like sunspot temperature, but they're planets.

Dominic

Yeah, so I yeah, th on the on the day sides they can get up to sunspot temperatures. a an analogy for people I give when I do public outreach is also if you think y about your oven, your oven can only typically go up to a couple of hundred degrees Celsius, right? For

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

for me, that's a very cold temperature in these atmospheres. So we would only find that

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

at like the coldest spots on a hot Jupiter is where we can get

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

down to couple hundred degrees Celsius. So that that would be really very cold. So whenever I talk about hot and cold, that's the framework I'm working with. Everything is hotter than the hottest setting on your your oven at home.

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

yeah, and so it's incredibly hot. And it's actually so hot that anything that would normally be a rock on Earth or metal on Earth is vaporized. It's in the gas phase. So you have

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

iron and silicon just floating around in the gas phase.

Jeni

Okay, so this is where the minerals and snowflakes idea comes in, right?

Dominic

Right. Exactly. So so this is the material which when it gets cold enough in the planet, remember that still means very hot, but it's cold enough, those materials then condense from the gas phase and form cloud particles. and when when we're

Jeni

Ayy.

Dominic

talking about particles here, we really mean micron sized particles. So very, very small flecks of almost dust. You can think of it as like like

Jeni

Yeah. Okay.

Dominic

yeah, like grains of sand. Almost.

Jeni

So it's more like when we're thinking about the clouds, they they are like dust clouds. So it's like iron dust or silicon dust or like magnesium dust, that kind of thing.

Dominic

Exactly, yeah. and so those are those are the materials that are able to form in these incredibly hot atmospheres. If you go to slightly cooler exoplanets as they get further away from their host are, you can start to have other materials condensing. So you can also have salt condensing, for example, sodium chloride and also potassium chloride its sort of twin version. They are then able

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

to start condensing out. And then eventually you get colder and colder

Jeni

Salt clouds.

Dominic

And then you come back into the regime where you have what we call volatiles, which are the materials that you probably more conventionally think of as forming clouds. So water,

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

methane, if you're f if the audience is familiar with Titan clouds, these are made of methane. So you have to get to much, much colder exoplanets to form those.

Jeni

So what triggers cloud formation when you're talking about like iron and and silicates and and those, you know, like dust particles? What what then like triggers a cloud to form?

Dominic

So what's what's really exciting about it is it's exactly the same processes that cause water for clouds to form. So that's

Jeni

yeah?

Dominic

that's where the similarities are the same. So it's completely different materials, completely different temperatures, but the mechanisms underlying it are the same. So you s

Jeni

So take us through those mechanisms.

Dominic

yeah, absolutely. So you have a you I want you to imagine a box of gas, right? and we're gonna do it with water vapor first of all, right? So if you have a a box and you fill it with water vapor, with steam. From a kettle or something, right? You have a box that is now what we call saturated in water vapor. That means it has a lot of water gas molecules in there. And then you can probably imagine in your mind in this box already, on the sides of that box is water droplets are going form, right? Everyone's familiar with this.

Jeni

Mm-hmm. Yeah.

Dominic

And so that process of water droplets forming on a surface is called heterogeneous nucleation. and so it happens when you have this saturated gas. You fill your gas full of something that is able to condense, and the temperature is just right, and then what it needs is some surface. you can do it completely

Jeni

yeah.

Dominic

without a surface, but then you have to put so much more vapor into the box

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

to do that. And so it's more efficient if there's some surface that can kickstart this process.

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

for water clouds on Earth, that is little flecks of material that come from the surface of Earth. So it can be salt coming up from ocean spray over the oceans, it can be dust from the deserts over Sahara, it can also be even s things like bacteria get lofted up into the atmosphere by strong

Jeni

Hmm. Yeah.

Dominic

upwinds, and then they can act as these little seeds for cloud water droplets to form around. and so in our moving to our completely different frame, these very hot planets, is exactly the same pro process, but remember I said these are gas giants. So there's no surface there.

Jeni

Yeah. Mm.

Dominic

So you have to find a way to make that surface first. And so you have to go back to the other mechanism I said, which is you just have to really saturate the gas. You have to have lots and lots of this material at

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

at very cold temperatures. Well, very cold for compared to when the material should transition from gas to solid.

Jeni

Mm-hmm.

Dominic

and then you can for some materials and only some, it's possible to stick the molecules together. one by one until they form a little cluster. This is called homogeneous nucleation. And it's a very, very slow and inefficient process. But at the

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

end of it you form your little seed and then all of the rest of your gases that are floating around can now condense onto that. So

Jeni

Okay, and that seed is the same material as then everything else that's condensing down.

Dominic

it doesn't have to be. So once your surface

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

is there, you

Lorenzo

Hmm.

Dominic

know, just like the water can condense on the glass surface, other

Jeni

Yeah, on like yeah.

Dominic

materials can condense onto this one. And so you have these key key

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

molecules that can kick start the con condensation of everything else.

Jeni

I've got you. Right. And so this is all the microphysics then that you're modeling. Yeah.

Dominic

Yeah, exactly. So these are all the juicy details that you have to dig into if you want to accurately capture this whole process. You can as always in science make a lot of simplifications to try and

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

understand the clouds without understanding these processes, that I do focuses on really understanding these steps that start the cloud formation

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

and then what happens after that.

Lorenzo

So is it here that the snowflake happens when you coal down all this very hot gas into form this little seed? So you're also

Dominic

Yes.

Lorenzo

telling me that this little seed that is starting clouds on other planets is a snowflake because this is so cool.

Dominic

Well, so the cluster itself is probably pretty spherical. But then the growth that happens after it, it's chaotic, it's disorganized, you have all these different gases that

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

are able to condense. They're all competing for each other. So that's maybe a big difference from the Earth case. On Earth, we really only have one material that can condense in our atmosphere. Right? It's always water condensation in in the atmosphere. We can make other materials condense in a lab, say, but in the atmosphere it's always water. In a hot Jupiter, you have all these different materials that can Condense. And so they are

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

competing with each other to condense onto this surface. And so the idea we had is that we usually assume that they still grow as pretty much little spheres, little spherical dust particles. But given the the lack of understanding we have about the details of this process, what if they actually form little snowflakey like shapes? And I say snowflake-like

Jeni

And so these, yeah.

Dominic

because they probably don't look like snowflakes, because the structure of a snowflake comes from the bonding structure that water produces.

Lorenzo

Yeah, but don't don't take this away from us. Now I we're all gonna imagine

Dominic

Ha ha ha.

Lorenzo

there was a snowflakes and we want to keep doing that. Please.

Jeni

Yeah. And I guess 'cause you said as well snowflakes because they're when you're forming these seeds it's at comparatively cooler temperatures as well, right? Is that right?

Dominic

Yeah, so we assume that they form the solid version of the condensate. So we're not forming droplets of liquid silicates and metals, but solid versions. And so that's why we liken it to the snowflakes, which are the solid form of of ice condensates.

Jeni

Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then once you've got your snowflakes, then you get your clouds.

Dominic

Yeah, s yeah, well it's so it's the clouds that particles that are forming the snowflakes. Yeah. Like the the clusters themselves will be pretty much spheres. They're they're very small. So there's not

Jeni

okay, so the snowflakes are the clouds.

Dominic

Yeah, exactly. So you form the little clusters and then the rapid growth after that is what can potentially form not spherical particles, some sort of irregular shape.

Lorenzo

Given how complicated and inefficient, as we say before, this this method to form cloud is, it looks to me like it's kind of a local phenomenon, right? More than something more general happening all at the same time everywhere on the planet. And I'm just thinking that we all used to simulate planets or think about planets like one column of atmosphere, one average version of the planet, one point. everywhere is the same. But it looks to me that this local effect that you are describing is bringing us to that probably that to the model that you were that we mentioned before.

Dominic

Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. So we can finally build up the the layers to get to why the planets are not all the same everywhere. So this

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

process is very dependent on the temperature and the pressure that is like Lorenzo said, local to the process happening. And it also happens quite still quite quickly on planetary timescales. And so what you have is the possibility that if it's hotter at one part of an atmosphere than another. then you can have clouds forming in the cool regions and then when it's hotter their clouds are evaporating. You know, exactly like we we

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

have on on Earth as well, right? We have regions where we have lots of clouds over England, say. And then you have regions where there's

Jeni

Hey.

Dominic

a there's a lot less clouds over say Arizona. Yeah.

Jeni

Not over Wales. No.

Dominic

Way is very good for for nucleating clouds, apparently

Jeni

yeah, we're like experts here.

Dominic

Yeah. and so maybe I can explain the the two D nature then. So

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

we know that

Lorenzo

Please.

Dominic

the these planets are really not one D, right? They're not yeah, they they are three dimensional objects, of course, they're spheres.

Lorenzo

Yeah, not flat, you're saying.

Dominic

Exactly, they're not flat, they're not a s a single line. but when we when we assume they're the same everywhere, that's essentially how we model them. We assume that they are just one vertical column going from deep in the atmosphere to the to the top of the atmosphere. So these planets, like I said, they orbit their star very closely. And so they're what's called tidally locked. And

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

so that's the process that happened to the moon with the Earth. It's where gravitational

Jeni

Mm-hmm.

Dominic

interaction between the star and the planet causes it to rotate so that one side is always facing the star and one side is facing away. So, Jenny, in your very nice introduction, you you mentioned about days and night sides. So these are the terms that we use to describe these two hemispheres of the planet. One is facing the star permanently, that's a permanent dayside, and one is facing Way, that's a permanent night side. So you have these two sides. One of them is very hot, the other is comparatively cooler. And so

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

what that does is that generates winds that flow around the planet, right? Because

Jeni

Yeah, that makes sense.

Dominic

when it's hot you have high pressure, and when it's cold, you have low pressure. And so the wind is being

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

driven from the dayside to the night side. And then the planet,

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

of course, is rotating, and so you have rotational effects, Coriolis force, etc. That continue to drive that flow and make other interesting flow patterns. But the main picture I want you to have in your

Jeni

Hey.

Dominic

head is you have this flow that is starting from the day side, it's going round to the night side, and then because of momentum, it continues round. And so you get this circulation that goes in the same direction as the planet. So you other very clever people can run numerical simulations of this flow. They're called GCMs, general circulation models. And for Hot Jupiters, they end up with this feature called an equatorial jet. So this is a band, sort of like the bands on Jupiter, but you only have

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

one on these hot Jupiters and it's very strong. It's around

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

the equator of the planet and it's very, very fast, incredibly fast. We're talking kilometers per second wind speeds in this jet. Yeah.

Jeni

My god. That was flatten you. absolutely squish you.

Lorenzo

And I and I was thinking that the bad the the weather was bad here for umbrellas in Wales. Can you imagine that?

Jeni

Ha ha ha

Dominic

Yeah. Yeah, so it's a very hostile environment. I don't know if we're ever sending an astronaut to one of these planets, but if we do,

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

we're gonna it's gonna be a serious engineering challenge to to survive in these environments. Incredibly hot and these mega hurricane wind speeds that are happening. But so because of this rotation round the planet. If I I want you now to think about the edges of the planet. So remember, one side is always facing the dayside and one side is always facing away. And so at the at the boundary between those two, you have what we call the terminator. not Anna Schwarzenegger, unfortunately.

Jeni

Not Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Dominic

yeah, fun fact, the Space Research Institute in Austria is in a town called Graz. The village where Anne Schwarzenegger grew up is just up i in the mountains near two Graz. It's a sh it's a short road trip out. You you can do a day trip there, so

Jeni

I love that. I love that. And I know that when they dubbed over like Arnold Schwarzenegger for in the different languages, they had to like dub him over. they couldn't let him speak German because like according to Germans he had a farmer's accent. So th he they had to like get someone else to like dub him over in German.

Dominic

Yeah, so he has a he has a a s a Styrian accent, which is the state Graz is in, which is a very rural state in Austria, and so it has this real, yeah,

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

country vibe to it. so it doesn't the I'll be back doesn't quite sound so impressive in in in in

Jeni

No.

Dominic

his Styrian accented German.

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

but yeah, so so that's a tangent. So these these terminators on the planet, they are being subjected to this flow going around. And one of them is seeing The winds coming from the dayside as they're heading towards the night side. Right? So we

Jeni

Yes, yep.

Dominic

call this the evening terminator because it's seeing winds going from day to night, even though itself

Jeni

Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. Hmm.

Dominic

always stays at permanent evening. Right? It's never getting the sun rising or setting apparent from that spot on the planet. And so obviously, the other side is seeing the winds coming from the night side to the dayside. This we call the morning

Jeni

Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Dominic

terminator. And so Because the winds are flowing from these different parts of the planet, the evening terminator is seeing very hot gas coming from the day side of the planet. And the morning terminator is seeing very cold gas coming from the evening side of the planet. important. The evening terminator is seeing hot winds coming from the day side of the planet, and the morning terminator is seeing very cold gas coming from the night side of the planet.

Jeni

Yes, yeah.

Dominic

Right. And so we can come back to our cloud and our what we know about that now, which is we expect because it's colder on the morning terminator, more clouds to form there and less clouds to form on the hotter evening terminator.

Jeni

Yeah, okay, I got you. Yeah, because you

Dominic

And so finally we have arrived at our our wonky planet, right? It has one side which is full

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

of clouds and the other side which is potentially very clear skies.

Jeni

Because I remember you saying about how you need comparatively cooler temperatures to form those nucleation points. So that makes sense. This is this is excellent.

Dominic

Right, exactly. Right, exactly.

Lorenzo

So this will result probably in a difference in shape then, right? 'Cause the planet is gonna be clearer on one side with more clouds on the other, right? So it is is this

Dominic

Yes, exactly.

Lorenzo

observable? Can we see that?

Jeni

So yeah, so is in like

Dominic

Absolutely.

Jeni

physically then the the whole planet is off centre. Is that what you're saying, Lorenzo?

Lorenzo

What yeah, what I'm saying is that physically speaking the planet is gonna look like not like a not like a circle anymore.

Jeni

Yeah.

Lorenzo

More like a a a rotated balloon, right? Which is more spherical circular

Jeni

Yeah, I yeah.

Lorenzo

in one side when it's clear, and well a a little not so so spherical on the other side, like he has some fat there which is

Dominic

Ha ha.

Lorenzo

This month of cloud

Jeni

Mm.

Lorenzo

probably. I just wondering is is is this something that we can we can see? Maybe we WST?

Dominic

Absolutely. So we have now several detections of asymmetries, which is what we use for this yeah, that's the word we use for

Lorenzo

Asymmetries, right? That's the right word.

Dominic

these wonky wonkiness in the planets.

Jeni

But are they physically wonky or is it just like they appear wonky because you're seeing clouds in one area and not seeing clouds in another area? Or are they actually physically wonky?

Lorenzo

Is there a difference from being or appearing walking on this on this?

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

we can devolve

Jeni

This is amazing.

Dominic

into philosophy very quickly.

Lorenzo

It's all gas, right? I mean it's all gas in these planets, yeah for Jupiter.

Dominic

are there are there are multiple there are multiple effects that happen. So I'm just talking about the clouds because I'm a cloud modeler. But actually indeed there is a physical wonkiness to the planet as well, which is because it's so hot on the day side and at the evening Terminator, those parts of the planet are actually more extended, more puffed up.

Jeni

Mm, mm.

Dominic

As you heat up a gas, it expands. And so those parts of the planets are more extant expanded. And then the night

Jeni

Right.

Dominic

side and the morning terminator are more compact. So that's another effect that you have to take into account.

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

And so there were there have been observations with James Webb. The first one that was published was a paper led by Nestas Binoza in 2023, which I was a co-author on, for the planet Wasp 39B, which showed this asymmetry. So we were able to see. The terminators of the planet as it passed in front of its

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

star from fr i as viewed from Earth, it passed in front of its star. And then we're able to see the atmosphere. And we those two sides of the planet, you're able to derive spectra for one side, for the morning side, and one for the evening. And then you can compare the two and you can see that the morning side has a flatter spectrum, which is due to the clouds blocking our view of the deeper parts of the atmosphere. And the evening side, which is clearer, has bigger features from the gas phase. These are bumps that you can see because of molecules like CO two and you can see them in the evening side and then they're more muted in the morning side of the planet.

Jeni

my god, that's amazing that you can actually see that.

Lorenzo

So let let me let me help rephrasing it a little, just so I can grab some concept from season one back. So we're talking about transmission spectroscopy here. So when the planet

Dominic

Yes.

Lorenzo

in front of the star, a pe a little piece of the star light goes through the planet atmosphere and clouds, right? So what you are seeing is that on one side, when we're looking through the clouds, we just see no clouds and we see the molecules of the atmosphere. While on the other side, when we're looking to the clouds, because of the clouds We just see flatness in the spectra. Basically we don't see the molecules because the clouds are obscuring them. Is that is that a good way of seeing it? Is correct?

Dominic

Yeah, exactly. sometimes for the for the cloudy side, sometimes it is we we see a completely flat or a little bit of a of a of a slope, but sometimes you can still see the features, but they are smaller than on the evening side. So you can see that you're seeing yeah.

Lorenzo

I see, yeah. And that's how you can say it, yeah.

Jeni

So with our wonky balloon, is our big bulgy side is on is on like the the evening terminator where it's hotter and then the it's a bit smaller on the morning terminator side.

Dominic

Yeah, so it the that effect is a little harder to see, but it does play into it. So overall the size of these features that you see in the transmission spectroscopy is larger for the evening and they're smaller for the morning. And that's a combination

Jeni

Hmm. Hmm.

Dominic

of many effects. and there is one final effect that can make the planets look different on these two sides, which I haven't said yet, which is also

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

the ke the chemistry is changing. So because the temperature changes, which molecules are stable in the atmosphere also changes.

Jeni

Yeah, that makes sense. Yeah.

Dominic

And so you have some molecules that appear on the cooler morning side that are not present on the hotter evening side because it's so hot

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

that even the gas molecules are what we call dissociated broken apart and they form something else. and so yeah, so you have to combine all three of these processes together the chemistry difference, the extent of the atmosphere difference, and the cloudiness difference to understand these two sides of the planet.

Jeni

And so then this all goes into these two D models that you're doing, right? So so can

Dominic

Right.

Jeni

you take us through how you like put all of that information into these two dimensional models?

Dominic

Yeah, so i i it's a it's a great question. So we actually start from three-dimensional models. These are those general circulation models that I talked about before, but

Jeni

Okay. Yeah.

Dominic

we can't do all of the complex modeling in these three-dimensional models. They're very computationally expensive, they take a long time to run. Right. So we usually take a s

Jeni

Right, so you have to make assumptions there. So then you go down to two D.

Dominic

a simple 3D model and then we take data from that and we use that as input into the two D model.

Jeni

Hm. Okay.

Dominic

And the 2D model is just simulating around the equator of the planet. So it's just

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

the equator. It's got a, you know, we you can go up and down in the atmosphere, and then you can go round and round the planet. That's the two dimensions that we allow in the model.

Jeni

Yeah, okay.

Dominic

and then what what I use is is called 2D Karma. It's a cloud formation code, which was originally an Earth cloud formation code. So it was originally built to study

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

water condensation on Earth.

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

And it's been adapted to work for these hot environments. So the 2D model allows us to simulate the clouds forming locally at some point in the atmosphere and then how they are moved around by the winds that are going round and round the equator of this planet. So then we're able to see if they're able to be brought all the way around the planet, or if at some point they're brought

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

to a part of the atmosphere where it's so hot that they evaporate again. and then that gas is then still moved around and can come back to a colder part of the planet where it can recondense as clouds again. And so you have this cloud cycle around the planet.

Jeni

And I guess that's what you're missing if you just do the one dimensional model, right? Is

Dominic

Right. Exactly.

Jeni

y is this cyclic nature and how how it can change, over time and right?

Dominic

Yeah, and you can't you can't capture the different hot and cold parts of the planet at the same time. In

Lorenzo

Right.

Dominic

one one with a 1D model you have to pick what the temperature as a function of height. So how does the temperature change as you go up in the atmosphere? You have to pick one profile for that, and then you're stuck you're stuck with it. And that profile will either have clouds or not. But in the two D approach, you can have some parts of the atmosphere where it's cold enough to form these clouds, and then other parts that are hotter, and

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

the clouds can move between those two regions. And so you get f cycles between cloud forming regions and places where it evaporates again 'cause it's too hot.

Jeni

And so is it does it take ages to run these? Is it like you kinda set the codes going and you you you go away to I don't know, you go off to Spain for a week and then you come back and it's like ready for you or is it

Dominic

I wish I wish we had the budget to go to Spain every week. We run models. But

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

so so, like a lot of these things, it's a it's different scales. So the 3D general circulation models are more difficult to run. So they take longer. They take like weeks to run. these cloud models take on the order of hours to days to run. So It's significantly cheaper than the 3D models, but there are much simpler atmosphere models which we use directly on the data when you're trying to understand the data directly. Those models are supposed to run in milliseconds, each instance of the model. so that you can try you the basically with the observations you s have these very crap fast models, and then you try lots of different combinations of the assumptions of the model, and you try to find the best one that fits the data. And you have

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

a mechanism of trying all these different models. So they run incredibly quickly. You can't do that with these more expensive models that my work relies on. they just simply take too long. So if you imagine in the very fast case you're running millions of models, well, each one of mine takes, say, a day to run. So that's a million days to to run it.

Jeni

So when you then run the models, you your like the two D ones, there's not so many, but then I guess this because you've got this two D nature that there's so many layers, there's a lot more information in them even though there's fewer models. And so then that can be used to interpret like the JWST data very effectively.

Dominic

Yeah, and there's a great f feedback between these two kinds of approaches. So you we have to use the information that we get from the very simple models with the data to inform how we choose to set up the two D models. because that will help us

Jeni

Mm. Yeah. Just to do it smartly.

Dominic

Right, you could make a model that has a lot of of clouds in it, but if the data from the observations doesn't say that there's a lot of clouds there, then there's no point running

Jeni

Then what's the point?

Dominic

that model, right? Exactly. So we use that information to feedback.

Jeni

It's beautiful. It's like everything is helping everything. And it's just like, you know, the atmosphere is all entangled and it's like feeding around and then it's like the models feeding the data, the data's feeding the models. it's beautiful symmetry. I love it.

Dominic

Yeah.

Lorenzo

It's an amazing picture, it's really a fantastic picture. And

Jeni

Mm.

Lorenzo

I think we can take this picture with us now because

Jeni

Yeah. As we as we wrap up, just like the clouds are wrapping aro Oh look at this. It's beautiful.

Dominic

Mm-hmm.

Lorenzo

Yeah amazing yes to the final final question

Jeni

Yeah.

Lorenzo

So Dominique if you had to choose one celestial body that represents you or your work, what would it be and why?

Dominic

Yeah, so I had to I had to think a lot for this. I'm gonna cheat slightly and I'm gonna pick two bodies. but they're in it's I I think it's I think I can get

Jeni

Don't know if we'll allow that, Dominic. I don't know if we can allow it.

Lorenzo

Shall we allow it?

Dominic

away with it. It's one planetary system. So I'm an exoplanet scientist, so I had to go and find an exoplanet

Jeni

Okay.

Lorenzo

Okay, okay, fair enough, fair enough.

Dominic

that that fits me. so it's called K the Kepler one seven system.

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

there are actually multiple planets in this system. But I just want to focus on two, B and C. These are two planets with very similar radii to each other. They're about the same size. Incredibly similar actually. They're both about one and a half Earth radii. And so they've been given variously a moniker as twin planets, because they look very similar.

Jeni

Okay.

Dominic

and I am a twin, and so I thought this system was great.

Jeni

I was wondering if that's where it was going 'cause you were picking twin plants in my brain. I was like, I wonder if it's cause he's a twin. Amazing. Carry on.

Dominic

Yeah. And what's great about these planets is they have the same size, but they have very different densities. So they're very different on the inside. And me and my brother are identical

Jeni

Mm.

Dominic

twins, so I feel a lot of affinity for this. We're very similar on the outside, but on the inside

Jeni

Yeah.

Dominic

we're very different people. So that's my selection for it, is Kepler one seven B and C.

Jeni

I love that. Yeah.

Lorenzo

It's so beautiful.

Jeni

I love that. You see another really insightful answer to our question to wrap up the show.

Lorenzo

How personal is this?

Dominic

Thank you.

Jeni

I know. It's lovely.

Dominic

Yeah, I had to get on the NASA Exoplanet Archive database and go searching for something like this. But but

Jeni

Yeah, be like to imply

Lorenzo

Ha ha.

Jeni

it's where are they? Where are they? Yeah.

Lorenzo

There must be out there.

Dominic

there are six thousand we know. I was certain that there must be some system I could find to make this work.

Jeni

That's got twin planets. I love that. It's beautiful. That's a really beautiful answer.

Lorenzo

It's amazing. Dominic, thank you. Thank you for showing us that planets are messier, more loopsided, and far more interesting than our neat models would like them to be.

Dominic

Thank you very much for having me. It's been great talking to you.

Jeni

It has. It's genuinely this has been a really great episode. So thank you so much for coming on. And a big thank you to everyone listening. Join us next time on Growing Worlds as we explore another corner of the universe and the people bringing it closer.